Knowledge Marketplace
My First Million

My First Million

The best business ideas come from noticing what's working and doing it better, faster, or for a different audience.

Back to Frameworks

Dumb vs Dumbass Decision Framework

Reusability

A framework distinguishing between lack of intelligence (dumb) and poor judgment despite intelligence (dumbass). Dumb means lacking cognitive ability, while dumbass means having intelligence but consistently making poor decisions.

How It Works

Smart people can make terrible decisions due to ego, impulse, or lack of empathy rather than lack of capability. The framework helps identify whether poor outcomes stem from incompetence or bad judgment.

Components

1

Assess baseline intelligence/capability

2

Identify pattern of decision quality

3

Determine if failures stem from knowledge gaps or judgment lapses

4

Apply appropriate intervention

When to Use

When evaluating leadership failures, hiring decisions, or assessing whether someone can improve their decision-making

When Not to Use

When dealing with technical skills assessment or genuine capability gaps that require training

Anti-Patterns to Avoid

Assuming smart people always make good decisionsExcusing bad judgment as lack of knowledgeFailing to address judgment issues in leadership roles

Example

A brilliant CEO who understands business fundamentals but repeatedly makes public relations disasters by insulting customers on social media - they're not dumb, they're being a dumbass